TURKISH SCHOLARS ARE ACCUSED OF BEING PAID OFF BY ARMENIANS
15-11-2005 13:40:00 | USA | Articles and Analyses
By Harut Sassounian
Publisher, The California Courier
Turkish establishment's displeasure with the three
independent Turkish scholars who spoke at UCLA on November 6,
expressing their disagreement with the Turkish government's
denialist views on the Armenian Genocide, keeps escalating.
Before the conference, professors Taner Akcam, Fatma Muge
Gocek and Elif Shafak received insulting and threatening e-mails
from individual Turks. Then the Turkish Students' Association
at UCLA offered to fly a denialist "scholar" all the way from
Turkey to counter the three Turkish speakers, a suggestion that
was declined.
Now the Turks are accusing these scholars of being paid by
Armenians for their anti-establishment views. Milliyet reported
in its Nov. 9 issue that the Turkish Consul General in Los
Angeles Engin Ansay had told Alper Nakri, the reporter for the
Dogan News Agency in Los Angeles, that Akcam earns $5,000 to
$7,000 for taking part in such conferences. Ansay was quoted as
saying: "The participants [of the UCLA conference] are
pseudo-scholars. Akcam and Gocek are rendering this service for
fame and fortune, in a highly conscious manner, and perhaps even
in spite of their own beliefs." Needless to say, this accusation
deeply offended the three scholars. Even though this was not the
first time that Turkish journalists and officials had slandered
them for challenging the Turkish government's denials of the
Armenian Genocide, it was the first time that such an accusation
was made in the United States, thus making the slanderous
article actionable under US libel laws.
Before considering any legal action, however, Prof. Gocek
said in an e-mail that she contacted the Turkish Consul General
to confirm Milliyet's report. Mr. Ansay denied making those
statements. Then someone from Milliyet contacted Dr. Akcam,
asking him to write a rebuttal.
While we cannot be certain whether or not the Consul
General was misquoted, most Turkish newspapers are notorious for
publishing unsubstantiated and unverified news items. Even
though from time to time someone has the courage and patience to
sue them, the publishers of these papers consider the payment of
court-mandated fines as the cost of doing business. Because of
their lack of journalistic standards, I have always refused all
interview requests by the Turkish media. No amount of subsequent
corrections or retractions could undo the damage to one's
reputation after a distorted version of one's words is
published.
TRT (Turkish State Radio and Television) and CNN-Turk are
reportedly coming to the United States in a few weeks to
interview Armenian Americans on Turkish-Armenian relations.
Regrettably, some Armenians are going to accept to be
interviewed by these Turkish TV stations either out of a desire
to see themselves on TV or naïvely thinking that they would be
educating the Turks on Armenian issues. Afterwards, when they
see that their statements are distorted, they then blame the
Turkish media and try to convince their fellow Armenians that
they didn't really make those terrible statements! Complaining
after an interview is distorted does not help matters. We need
to learn from the sad experiences of thousands of others who
have been victimized by the Turkish media over the years.
Refusing to speak to the Turkish media is the best way to stay
out of trouble!